Mariah Carey was one of the many A-list performers to perform on American Idol’s “Idol Gives Back” special last week.

We just caught her performance a second time on YouTube, and can’t help but ask ourselves if she is singing, lipsynching, or a little bit of both…

What do you think?

Other stories you might love:

1. American Idol Does NASDAQ In Times Square!
2. American Idol Winner Kris Allen Releases First Single!
3. Adam Lambert Kisses And Tells!
4. Ellen Does Idol!
5. First Look! 37th Annual American Music Awards Promo!